The Shire Shop

Site Map

The Return of the King Soundtrack Review

The Return of the King, the third and final installment to the Lord of the Rings Trilogy. Great movie but how about the soundtrack? We'll if you were to ask me that question I would say exactly this: "It's a bit of a disappointment, however, there are some songs that are just so incredibley good that it's worth owning the CD just for those songs alone - 'Shelob's Lair' and 'Minas Tirith' are some of the best songs of the trilogy." "Shelob's Lair" is so good that I would rank it as high as "The Bridge of Khazad Dum" off The Fellowship of the Ring Soundtrack. The first time I heard Shelob's Lair I was amazed but it suffered the same fate that "The Bridge of Khazad Dum" did and got butchered in the movie, which was disappointing. However, in my opinion those two songs tie for the best songs of the entire Trilogy.

A brief review of some the ups and downs of the Soundtrack. The score starts off with the classic intro music heard in the beginning of the movies, it then moves into a brighter mood with some lighter flute sounds and basically goes right along with the scene of Smeagol fishing with Deagol and quickly goes into roaring brass and violins heard in the fight and murder scene. Skipping to "Minas Tirith", it quickly became on of my favorite songs when I went to see ROTK for the second time. The best part of the song is during the scene that features Gandalf with Pippin riding through the White City. The song is absolutely brilliant.

On "Steward of Gondor" Billy Boyd (Pippin) makes his debut on the Soundtracks and sings! The first time I heard it, before I saw the movie, I thought "oh no", but the song is actually not that bad. "Minas Morgul", very cool dark song, too bad it's just under two minutes long, this is the scene where the Witchking rises above Minas Morgul on his winged beast.

"Twilight and Shadow" features Renée Fleming, who she is I don't know nor do I care the song is not very good...Moving on to "Ash and Smoke", fantastic song features both dark and bright music and is certainly one of my favorites - some very strong horns in this one. "The Fields of Pelennor", finally the choir returns, where have they been? This song features some very strong chorus vocals and then finishes with an absolutely awesome part from the horn section.

Sadly, the soundtrack starts to head south from here... Frustrating that the last four songs are the four longest and are rather weak songs, makes you wish some the highlight songs on the soundtrack could be longer. If your having trouble sleeping, put on the track "The Return of the King" it should help put you to sleep in no time.

Once again they had to make us suffer with another lame track to close the soundtrack, Into the West. Sorry to Anne Lennox fans but the song is so lame and like the previous two soundtracks it's song that just doesn't belong! I'd be absolutely embarassed if anyone saw me listening to that song... All in all, it's a decent soundtrack, it's still a landslide victory for Fellowship of the Ring which is the best of the three soundtracks. The music goes well with the movie but if you try and look at as a CD and not a movie you'll see that many of the songs are just mediocre. If you like the previous two soundtracks then I'd say you'll like this album too because some of the songs are simply amazing.


Album Breakdown:

1. A Storm is Coming
2. Hope and Memory
3. Minas Tirith
4. The White Tree
5. The Steward of Gondor
6. Minas Morgul
7. The Ride of the Rohirrim
8. Twilight and Shadow
9. Cirith Ungol
10. Andúril
11. Shelob's Lair
12. Ash and Smoke
13. The Fields of the Pelennor
14. Hope Fails
15. The Black Gate Opens
16. The End of All Things
17. The Return of the King
18. The Grey Havens
19. Into the West

4.0
3.0
5.0 +++
5.0
3.0
5.0 +++
4.0
2.0
2.5
3.5
5.0 +++ Best Track!
5.0 +++
5.0
3.0
3.0
3.5
2.5
2.5
1.5

Overall Rating:

82%

+++ = Absolutely Fantastic Song!

 Lord of the Rings ...
  Action Figures
  Board Games
  Bows
  Busts & Statues
  Chess Sets
  Collectibles
  Costumes
  Crystal Cubes
  Decor
  DVDs
  Goblets
  Jewelry
  Journals
  Miniatures 
  Mini Swords 
  Music 
  Pipes 
  Postcards 
  Posters 
  Standees 
 Harry Potter Store 
 LOTR Character Info 
 LOTR Links 
 Contact Us 
 FAQ 
 Terms of Service